Europe Faces Challenges in Strategic Battery Funding Amid Market Oversupply

EU Battery

European countries are struggling to adopt a unified and strategic approach to funding domestic battery supply chains as global oversupply of battery materials, led by China, continues to push prices lower through at least 2030. These issues were a key focus of the Future Battery Forum held this week in Berlin, Germany.

Oversupply in Battery Materials

The battery materials market, including nickel and cobalt, faces oversupply due to significant production increases from Indonesia and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). According to Siyamend Al Barazi, head of unit mineral economics at Germany’s Dera (German Mineral Resources Agency), "markets will be oversupplied at least until 2030." China's state subsidies, estimated at $230 billion from 2009 to 2023, have further contributed to this glut, maintaining downward pressure on global prices.

European Critical Raw Material Challenges

Despite the establishment of the EU Critical Raw Material Act (CRMA), which identifies 34 critical and 17 strategic materials vital to green and digital technologies, European funding efforts fall short of addressing the massive investment needs for battery material production and processing.

In September, Germany's KfW bank approved a €1 billion raw materials fund, while similar initiatives were launched by Italy, France, and the UK. However, panelists at the forum, including Jonathan Vanherberghen from Rio Tinto, argued that these amounts are insufficient for large-scale projects. For example, the capital expenditure for Rio Tinto's Jadar lithium project in Serbia alone stands at $2.5 billion.

Fragmented Funding and Industry Concerns

The fragmented funding landscape in Europe has made it difficult to pool resources effectively. Vanherberghen noted that funds like KfW’s could be more impactful if extended over longer periods to accommodate changing market cycles. Similarly, Cris Moreno, CEO of Vulcan Energy, highlighted that funding of at least $1 billion annually is required to meet the region’s ambitions. Moreno’s own lithium project in Germany has an estimated cost of $1.4 billion.

Despite the challenges, these funding initiatives provide some support by attracting institutional investors and fostering collaboration with car manufacturers, which are under increasing pressure to meet carbon targets and ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) standards.

Toward a Unified European Strategy

Experts at the forum emphasized the need for a more unified and sizeable funding mechanism to bolster Europe’s battery supply chain. A single, cohesive approach would allow Europe to compete with countries like China, South Korea, and Japan, where government support for raw material projects is significantly more robust.

Vanherberghen concluded, "Funds like that will only support projects with the highest ESG standards. Bringing these things together could create a much more effective system than the fragmented approach currently in place."